Deaths on February 3

Nasim Hasan Shah, Pakistani lawyer and judge, 12th Chief Justice of Pakistan (b. 1929)

Dr. Nasim Hasan Shah (Urdu: نسیم حسن شاہ), a distinguished Pakistani jurist, served as the Chief Justice of Pakistan from April 17, 1993, to April 14, 1994. Born on April 15, 1929, and passing away on February 3, 2015, Justice Shah left an indelible mark on Pakistan's legal and political landscape through his landmark judgments and extensive career in the judiciary.

A Legacy Defined by Pivotal Judgments

Justice Nasim Hasan Shah's tenure on the Supreme Court was punctuated by several highly significant and often controversial rulings that shaped the trajectory of Pakistan's constitutional and political history. His contributions as a jurist were profound, extending beyond the bench to influence legal discourse and constitutional interpretation in the nation.

The Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Verdict: A Controversial Chapter

Dr. Nasim Hasan Shah is perhaps most widely recognized for his prominent role in the Supreme Court's verdict concerning Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, the first democratically elected Prime Minister of Pakistan. Bhutto was accused of conspiring to murder a political opponent's father, Nawab Muhammad Ahmad Khan, and was convicted by the Lahore High Court. The subsequent appeal, heard by the Supreme Court, saw a split decision. Justice Shah was part of the seven-member bench that, by a narrow 4-3 majority, upheld the death sentence passed by the Lahore High Court. This verdict, delivered in 1979, remains one of the most contentious judicial decisions in Pakistan's history, frequently debated for its legal merits and the political climate in which it was delivered. Critics often cite concerns about due process and political interference, making it a critical case study in the annals of Pakistani jurisprudence.

Restoration of Parliament: Upholding Constitutional Sovereignty

Another monumental decision in Justice Shah's career was the Supreme Court's ruling to restore the National Assembly, which had been dissolved by then-President Ghulam Ishaq Khan on April 18, 1993. This landmark judgment, delivered on May 26, 1993, famously declared the presidential order unconstitutional and restored the government of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. Presiding over this pivotal case, Chief Justice Shah's bench asserted that the dissolution order was based on an "incorrect appreciation of the role assigned to the president and of the powers vested in him by the constitution." The verdict fundamentally clarified the delicate balance of power, firmly establishing that "the Prime Minister is not answerable to the President." Instead, the ruling emphasized that the President is constitutionally obligated to act on the advice of the Prime Minister, except in situations where explicit discretionary powers are granted by the constitution. This ruling was crucial in strengthening parliamentary democracy and limiting presidential overreach under Article 58(2)(b) of the Eighth Amendment, a provision often misused by presidents in the past to dismiss elected governments.

An Inspiring Career of Dedication and Resilience

Justice Nasim Hasan Shah's personal and professional journey was marked by remarkable resilience and intellectual brilliance. Despite his physical stature – standing 56 inches tall with a 50-inch girth – he transcended any perceived physical limitations to reach the pinnacle of the Pakistani judiciary. His academic career was stellar, culminating in a Doctorate of Law (with distinction) from the prestigious Paris University.

Following his advanced studies, he established a highly successful legal practice. His exceptional legal acumen led to his appointment as a High Court Judge at the remarkably young age of 39. He continued to serve with distinction, eventually ascending to the Supreme Court and, ultimately, becoming the Chief Justice. He retired from the Supreme Court at the constitutional age of 65. His total judicial service, spanning from his appointment as a High Court Judge until his retirement from the Supreme Court, represented one of the longest tenures by any judge in the history of the Indo-Pak subcontinent, a testament to his enduring commitment to the law.

Frequently Asked Questions about Justice Nasim Hasan Shah

Who was Dr. Nasim Hasan Shah?

Dr. Nasim Hasan Shah was a distinguished Pakistani jurist who served as the Chief Justice of Pakistan from 1993 to 1994. He is renowned for his significant contributions to Pakistani constitutional law through several landmark judgments.

What was Justice Shah's role in the Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto case?

Justice Nasim Hasan Shah was part of the Supreme Court bench that heard the appeal of former Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto. The bench, by a narrow majority, upheld the death sentence for the charge of murder conspiracy, a verdict that remains highly controversial.

How did Justice Shah contribute to the strengthening of democracy in Pakistan?

He presided over the Supreme Court bench that, in 1993, declared the dissolution of the National Assembly by President Ghulam Ishaq Khan unconstitutional and restored the government of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. This judgment significantly curtailed the President's discretionary powers and reinforced parliamentary supremacy in Pakistan.

What was notable about Justice Nasim Hasan Shah's judicial career length?

Justice Shah was appointed a High Court Judge at 39 and retired from the Supreme Court at 65. His combined service across the High Court and Supreme Court represents one of the longest judicial tenures in the history of the Indo-Pak subcontinent.