Deaths on January 5

Calvin Coolidge, American lawyer and politician, 30th President of the United States (b. 1872)

Calvin Coolidge, born John Calvin Coolidge Jr. on July 4, 1872, and passing away on January 5, 1933, holds a significant place in American history as the 30th President of the United States, serving from 1923 to 1929. A Republican lawyer hailing from New England, specifically Vermont, Coolidge’s political career was marked by a steady ascent through the ranks of Massachusetts state politics. His journey began in local government, progressing through the state legislature, and eventually culminating in his election as the Governor of Massachusetts.

The Boston Police Strike of 1919: A Defining Moment

Coolidge’s decisive response to the Boston Police Strike in September 1919 dramatically propelled him onto the national stage. When Boston police officers went on strike, demanding union recognition and improved working conditions, public safety was severely jeopardized. As Governor, Coolidge took a firm stance, declaring, "There is no right to strike against the public safety by anybody, anywhere, any time." He swiftly deployed the Massachusetts State Guard to restore order, earning widespread acclaim for his strong leadership and unwavering commitment to law and order. This pivotal event solidified his reputation as a man of principle and decisive action.

His newfound national prominence led to his nomination and subsequent election as the 29th Vice President of the United States in 1920, serving alongside President Warren G. Harding. Upon Harding’s sudden death in August 1923, Coolidge ascended to the presidency, taking the oath of office in a quiet ceremony at his family home in Plymouth Notch, Vermont. He was then elected to the presidency in his own right in 1924, winning with a substantial majority. Throughout his tenure, Coolidge cultivated a public image as a small-government conservative, advocating for fiscal restraint and limited federal intervention in the economy. He was also famously known for his reserved demeanor and dry wit, earning him the enduring nickname "Silent Cal." In a characteristic display of his understated style, he chose not to seek re-election in 1928, famously remarking that ten years in the presidency was (at the time) "longer than any other man has had it – too long!" This decision reflected both a personal inclination and a respect for the tradition of limiting presidential terms, even before the 22nd Amendment.

The Coolidge Presidency: Restoring Confidence and Fostering Prosperity

Coolidge’s presidency is often associated with a period of remarkable economic prosperity in the United States, popularly known as the "Roaring Twenties."

• Restoring Public Confidence: He skillfully navigated the aftermath of numerous scandals that plagued his predecessor’s administration, most notably the Teapot Dome scandal, which involved illicit oil leases. Coolidge’s quiet integrity and commitment to clean government played a crucial role in restoring public trust in the White House and the federal government.
• Economic Policies: A staunch advocate for a pro-business approach and what he termed "Coolidge Prosperity," he implemented policies designed to stimulate economic growth. These included significant tax cuts, particularly the Revenue Acts of 1924, 1926, and 1928, which reduced income and inheritance taxes, and a hands-off approach to governing, emphasizing deregulation and minimal government interference in the free market. His administration successfully reduced the national debt accumulated during World War I.
• Landmark Legislation: Among his significant legislative achievements was the signing into law of the Indian Citizenship Act of 1924. This landmark act granted full U.S. citizenship to all Native Americans born within the territorial limits of the United States, regardless of their tribal affiliation or reservation status, a crucial step toward recognizing their rights and contributions.
• Gubernatorial Philosophy: Throughout his earlier career as governor, Coolidge had consistently campaigned on a platform of fiscal conservatism, advocating for balanced budgets and responsible spending. Notably, he was also a strong and early supporter of women's suffrage, recognizing the importance of expanding democratic participation. While personally holding a vague opposition to Prohibition, he upheld his constitutional duty to enforce the law.

A biographer aptly captured his essence, stating: "He embodied the spirit and hopes of the middle class, could interpret their longings and express their opinions. That he did represent the genius of the average is the most convincing proof of his strength." This highlights his ability to connect with and represent the values of the average American during a transformative era.

Coolidge's Enduring Legacy and Historical Debate

The historical assessment of Calvin Coolidge's presidency remains a subject of considerable debate among scholars and historians. While some rankings place him in the lower half of U.S. presidents, a more nuanced understanding reveals both significant strengths and areas of critique.

Praise for Calvin Coolidge

• Stalwart Support for Racial Equality: Coolidge receives almost universal praise for his unwavering commitment to racial equality during a period marked by heightened racial tensions and the resurgence of the Ku Klux Klan. He consistently spoke out against prejudice and appointed African Americans to federal positions, demonstrating a commitment to civil rights rare for his time.
• Fiscal Responsibility: Advocates of smaller government and laissez-faire economics laud his policies for reducing the national debt, cutting taxes, and fostering a climate of economic prosperity without excessive government intervention. They view his administration as a golden age of free markets and limited government.

Criticisms of Calvin Coolidge

• Neglect of Struggling Sectors: Critics argue that Coolidge's hands-off approach meant a failure to adequately address the struggles of certain sectors, particularly farmers facing overproduction and declining prices, and workers in other industries like textiles and coal mining that were not experiencing the same boom. His veto of the McNary-Haugen Bill, which aimed to provide relief to farmers, is often cited as an example of this inaction.
• Role in the Great Depression: Perhaps the most significant and enduring debate revolves around the extent to which his economic policies contributed to the onset of the Great Depression. While the stock market crash of 1929 occurred soon after he left office, many historians, including his own Presidential Foundation, acknowledge that policies enacted under his administration, particularly those of the Federal Reserve System, played a role. The Federal Reserve's easy money policies and the lack of strong regulation on speculative investment during the "Coolidge Prosperity" are seen by some as having fueled the speculative bubble that eventually burst.

The complexity of his legacy underscores the ongoing historical analysis of his impact on American society and the economy.

FAQs About Calvin Coolidge

What was Calvin Coolidge's nickname?

Calvin Coolidge was widely known by the nickname "Silent Cal," a moniker that reflected his famously reserved demeanor, quiet nature, and often laconic public speaking style. Despite his quietness, he possessed a dry sense of humor.

What was Calvin Coolidge known for during his presidency?

During his presidency (1923-1929), Calvin Coolidge was primarily known for overseeing a period of significant economic prosperity, often referred to as the "Coolidge Prosperity" or part of the "Roaring Twenties." He was celebrated for his fiscal conservatism, tax cuts, reduction of the national debt, and a pro-business, hands-off approach to government. He also gained acclaim for restoring public confidence in the White House after his predecessor's scandals and for signing the landmark Indian Citizenship Act of 1924.

How did Calvin Coolidge become President?

Calvin Coolidge initially became President upon the sudden death of President Warren G. Harding on August 2, 1923. As the sitting Vice President, Coolidge automatically succeeded to the presidency. He was then elected to the office in his own right in the 1924 presidential election.

What was the Boston Police Strike of 1919 and how did Coolidge respond?

The Boston Police Strike of 1919 was a significant labor dispute where police officers in Boston went on strike, leading to a breakdown of law and order in the city. As Governor of Massachusetts, Calvin Coolidge responded decisively by deploying the state militia to restore order and famously declared, "There is no right to strike against the public safety by anybody, anywhere, any time." His firm action earned him national recognition and established his reputation as a strong leader.

Did Coolidge's policies contribute to the Great Depression?

Historians continue to debate the extent to which Coolidge's policies contributed to the Great Depression. While the stock market crash of 1929 occurred after he left office, some scholars and even his own Presidential Foundation acknowledge that his administration's economic policies, particularly the Federal Reserve's role in maintaining easy money and the lack of regulation on speculative investments, may have inadvertently contributed to the economic imbalances and speculative bubble that preceded the crash.