Charles Lee, English-American general (d. 1782)

Charles Henry Lee: A Controversial General of the American Revolution

Charles Henry Lee (6 February 1732 [O.S. 26 January 1731] – 2 October 1782) was a prominent and often controversial figure who served as a general in the Continental Army during the American Revolutionary War. Born in England, Lee's birthdate is presented with both Old Style (O.S.) and New Style dates due to the transition from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar in 18th-century Great Britain, with February 6, 1732, being the Gregorian equivalent of January 26, 1731, under the Julian calendar.

Early Military Career and European Adventures

Before his involvement in the American struggle for independence, Lee forged a significant military career in Europe. He served with distinction in the British Army during the Seven Years' War (1756–1763), a global conflict often referred to in North America as the French and Indian War. His experiences in this major international conflict provided him with invaluable battlefield knowledge and strategic insight. Following the conclusion of the Seven Years' War, Lee, known for his restless ambition and sometimes abrasive personality, sold his British commission. He then embarked on a new chapter, serving for a period in the Polish army under King Stanislaus II Augustus. During his time in Poland, a nation then facing significant political turmoil and external pressures leading to its eventual partitions, Lee held the rank of Major General and served as a military advisor, gaining further experience in European military and political affairs.

Arrival in America and Revolutionary Ambitions

In 1773, Lee made the decisive move to North America, acquiring an estate in what was then western Virginia (present-day West Virginia). His arrival coincided with escalating tensions between the American colonies and Great Britain. When armed conflict erupted in the American War of Independence in 1775, Lee, with his extensive European military background, quickly volunteered his services to the nascent rebel forces. His considerable experience and reputation were initially seen as a major asset to the Americans, who largely lacked professional military leadership. However, Lee's personal ambition was immense; he harbored a strong desire to be appointed Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Army, a role he felt uniquely qualified for given his superior European military credentials compared to many American-born officers. These aspirations were ultimately thwarted by the Continental Congress's decision to appoint George Washington to that pivotal post, a choice influenced by political considerations and Washington's strong reputation within Virginia and among the colonies.

Victories, Capture, and Controversial End

Lee's early contributions to the Revolutionary War were marked by significant successes. In 1776, forces under his command achieved a crucial victory by repulsing a British attempt to capture Charleston, South Carolina, during the Battle of Sullivan's Island. The successful defense of Fort Moultrie under his overall command was a major boost to American morale and solidified Lee's standing with both the Continental Army and the Continental Congress. Later that year, however, his fortunes dramatically shifted when he was captured by a patrol of British cavalry led by the notorious Banastre Tarleton in Basking Ridge, New Jersey, while separated from his main force. Lee remained a prisoner of the British until his exchange in 1778, a period that raised questions about his loyalty among some of his peers. His return to duty was short-lived and marred by controversy. During the Battle of Monmouth in June 1778, one of the largest and longest battles of the war, Lee led the advance element of the American forces in an assault on the British rear guard. However, his command of the attack miscarried, leading to a disordered retreat that drew the direct and public condemnation of General George Washington. This highly publicized confrontation led to Lee's court-martial on charges of disobedience of orders, misbehavior before the enemy, and disrespect to the Commander-in-Chief. Although some charges were acquitted, he was found guilty on others and suspended from command for a year, effectively bringing an end to his military service in the Continental Army. Charles Henry Lee passed away in Philadelphia in 1782, just as the war was drawing to a close, a figure whose early promise was ultimately overshadowed by ambition, misjudgment, and insubordination.

---

Frequently Asked Questions About Charles Henry Lee

What was Charles Lee's main role in the American Revolutionary War?

Charles Henry Lee served as a general in the Continental Army. Despite his ambition to be Commander-in-Chief, he played a key role in early victories, most notably the defense of Charleston in 1776, before his controversial conduct at the Battle of Monmouth led to his court-martial and the end of his service.

Why was Charles Lee court-martialed?

Charles Lee was court-martialed after the Battle of Monmouth in 1778 on charges of disobedience of orders, misbehavior before the enemy (specifically for ordering a retreat that led to confusion), and disrespect toward Commander-in-Chief George Washington. He was found guilty on several charges and suspended from command.

Did Charles Lee serve in any other armies besides the Continental Army?

Yes, Charles Lee had an extensive military background before joining the American Revolution. He served as an officer in the British Army during the Seven Years' War (French and Indian War) and later as a military advisor and general in the Polish army under King Stanislaus II Augustus.

How did Charles Lee's ambition affect his career?

Lee's significant ambition, particularly his desire to become Commander-in-Chief over George Washington, created tension and contributed to his later downfall. His perceived insubordination and disrespect toward Washington during and after the Battle of Monmouth were directly linked to his court-martial and the end of his military career.

What was the significance of the Battle of Charleston in Charles Lee's career?

The successful defense of Charleston (Battle of Sullivan's Island) in 1776 against a British naval and land assault was a major victory for the Americans and a high point in Charles Lee's career. It significantly boosted his reputation and standing within the army and Congress, showcasing his strategic capabilities before his later controversies.